Sage 50 P11D

Verified listing

Taxable benefits and expenses reporting with online submission to HMRC

4.1Based on 292 reviews

Visit website

Ratings by dimension

Ease of use3.9
Value3.9
Support4.0
Features4.0

Rating distribution

5 stars
120
4 stars
107
3 stars
35
2 stars
22
1 star
8

Filter reviews

Country

Industry

Company size

How long used

Sort by

Verified reviews for Sage 50 P11D

292 reviews matching your filters

Craig Thornley

Finance business partner · 501-1000 employees · Charity and non-profit

United Kingdom

4.0

16 Jun 2026

Company car calculations are the value

Company car calculations are correct and update each tax year. Only real gripe is that once you payroll benefits most of the need disappears.

Pros

Company car calculations are correct and update each tax year.

Cons

Once you payroll benefits most of the need disappears.

Ease of use: 4.0
Value for money: 3.0
Customer service: 3.0
Functionality: 3.0

Used for 1-2 years35 found this helpful

Hannah Stroud

Owner · 1-10 employees · Construction

United Kingdom

2.0

14 Jun 2026

Fine, but check if you still need P11D

The interface is very dated, and once you payroll benefits most of the need disappears. Class 1A comes out automatically and matches what we expected, which is about the only positive.

Pros

Class 1A comes out automatically and matches what we expected.

Cons

The interface is very dated.

Ease of use: 1.0
Value for money: 2.0
Customer service: 2.0
Functionality: 3.0

Used for 1-2 years9 found this helpful

Nicola Middleton

Sole trader · 11-50 employees · Education

United Kingdom

5.0

14 Jun 2026

Company car calculations are the value

Beneficial loan calculations used to take me a full day. Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch.

Pros

Beneficial loan calculations used to take me a full day.

Cons

The interface is very dated.

Ease of use: 4.0
Value for money: 5.0
Customer service: 5.0
Functionality: 5.0

Used for Less than 6 months6 found this helpful

Callum Bhatti

Company secretary · 201-500 employees · Legal services

United Kingdom

5.0

7 Jun 2026

Saved a day of manual work

Company car calculations are correct and update each tax year. Beneficial loan calculations used to take me a full day.

Pros

Company car calculations are correct and update each tax year.

Cons

Once you payroll benefits most of the need disappears.

Ease of use: 5.0
Value for money: 5.0
Customer service: 5.0
Functionality: 5.0

Used for 2+ years26 found this helpful

Stephen Mackenzie

Director · 1-10 employees · Manufacturing

United Kingdom

5.0

7 Jun 2026

Company car calculations are the value

Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch, and Class 1A comes out automatically and matches what we expected. No complaints so far.

Pros

Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch.

Cons

Hard to justify if you only have a handful of benefits.

Ease of use: 5.0
Value for money: 5.0
Customer service: 5.0
Functionality: 4.0

Used for 1-2 years19 found this helpful

Rachel Sinclair

Finance manager · 201-500 employees · Hospitality

United Kingdom

5.0

6 Jun 2026

Does one job properly

Class 1A comes out automatically and matches what we expected. Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch.

Pros

Class 1A comes out automatically and matches what we expected.

Cons

The interface is very dated.

Ease of use: 5.0
Value for money: 5.0
Customer service: 5.0
Functionality: 5.0

Used for Less than 6 months12 found this helpful

Ruth Iqbal

Bookkeeper · 11-50 employees · Accounting

United Kingdom

3.0

4 Jun 2026

Saved a day of manual work

Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch. That said, no published price, you have to ask and once you payroll benefits most of the need disappears.

Pros

Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch.

Cons

No published price, you have to ask.

Ease of use: 3.0
Value for money: 3.0
Customer service: 4.0
Functionality: 3.0

Used for 1-2 years28 found this helpful

Rebecca Quinn

Finance director · 501-1000 employees · IT services

United Kingdom

4.0

1 Jun 2026

Fine, but check if you still need P11D

Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch, and company car calculations are correct and update each tax year. The interface is very dated, but we live with it.

Pros

Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch.

Cons

The interface is very dated.

Ease of use: 4.0
Value for money: 4.0
Customer service: 4.0
Functionality: 4.0

Used for Less than 6 months19 found this helpful

Stephen Marsden

Bookkeeper · 11-50 employees · Veterinary

LinkedIn verifiedUnited Kingdom

5.0

31 May 2026

Worth it if you have a fleet

Beneficial loan calculations used to take me a full day. Online submission to HMRC went through without a hitch.

Pros

Beneficial loan calculations used to take me a full day.

Cons

No published price, you have to ask.

Ease of use: 5.0
Value for money: 5.0
Customer service: 4.0
Functionality: 5.0

Used for 2+ years3 found this helpful

Peter Lockhart

Payroll manager · 51-200 employees · Wholesale

United Kingdom

3.0

30 May 2026

Does one job properly

Mixed. Beneficial loan calculations used to take me a full day, but the interface is very dated.

Pros

Beneficial loan calculations used to take me a full day.

Cons

The interface is very dated.

Ease of use: 2.0
Value for money: 3.0
Customer service: 4.0
Functionality: 4.0

Used for 6-12 months11 found this helpful